Is there a more affordable alternative to Kiehl's Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector?
In the highly saturated world of skincare, finding effective yet affordable products can feel like a daunting task. For instance, how do you choose between premium brands with hefty price tags and their less-expensive alternatives? That was the precisely the question from one of our private Facebook group members who wanted to find a more affordable alternative to the Kiehl’s Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector which she mentioned was selling for $180 where she was located! That's where we come in.
We popped the Kiehl’s dark spot serum into our SKINSKOOL algorithm and just like that, we found a very credible alternative. The top INCI ingredient list match (8 out of 10 bars) for the premium Kiehl's Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector is the more budget-friendly IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Dark Spots Niacinamide Serum. Both of these brands are owned by L'Oreal, but their positioning and products are different. Nevertheless, the IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Dark Spots Niacinamide Serum is our choice for best affordable alternative to the Kiehl’s dark spot corrector.
SKINSKOOL gives IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Dark Spots a high 8 out of 10 bars INCI compare match score against the Kiehl's product.
Let's explore their claims, product and brand call-outs, and ingredient lists to see how they compare.
Product Claims
Kiehl's Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector is touted as a fast-acting serum that evens skin tone and diminishes dark spots to impart overall radiance and luminosity to the skin. Meanwhile, IT Cosmetics' Bye Bye Dark Spots Niacinamide Serum claims to be a breakthrough solution that visibly reduces the look of dark spots and hyperpigmentation for a more even skin tone. At the core of their promises, both products simply aim to target and fade dark spots.
Product and Brand Call-Outs
Kiehl's, an apothecary style skincare brand, is known for its premium, scientifically-backed skincare solutions using what they claim to be the finest naturally-derived ingredients. On the other hand, IT Cosmetics, which stands for Innovative Technology, prides itself on creating clinically tested, problem-solving products that give you serious beauty solutions. We think the branding of both IT Cosmetics and Kiehl's align closely, with neither explicitly fitting into any specialized category such as clean beauty. Incidentally, the 2 dropper bottles (minus the branding) look identical.
The Similarities in Ingredients
Both products share several key ingredients, such as Water/Aqua/Eau, Propylene Glycol, Glycerin, Hydroxypropyl Tetrahydropyrantriol, 3-o-ethyl Ascorbic Acid, Salicylic Acid, Phenoxyethanol, and Tocopherol. These commonalities suggest that they have a similar base formulation with hydrating, skin-brightening, and exfoliating properties.
The Differences in Ingredients
IT Cosmetics uniquely incorporates Niacinamide relatively high in the list, suggesting a significant concentration and in line with their call out of 4% in the product description. On the other hand, the Kiehl's product includes Alcohol Denat and Lavender Oil in its list, which are not found in the IT Cosmetics product.
The Order of Ingredients
As you likely already know, the order of ingredients in a skincare product is quite informative as ingredients are typically listed in descending order of concentration until you reach those that are present at less than 1% of the formula. This means that ingredients listed first are present in the highest amounts, while those at the end are present in the smallest amounts.
In the case of the IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Dark Spots Niacinamide Serum and the Kiehl's Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector, the beginning of the ingredient lists are remarkably similar. The presence of Aqua / Water / Eau, Propylene Glycol, Glycerin, Hydroxypropyl Tetrahydropyrantriol, 3-o-ethyl Ascorbic Acid (IT Cosmetics calls out 1% while Kiehl’s is silent), Phenoxyethanol, Salicylic Acid, Xanthan Gum, Sodium Citrate, and Potassium Hydroxide in both products and in similar order suggests a comparable formulation foundation.
Just a Friendly Reminder
While we're totally jazzed about comparing these products and finding potential dupes, it's important to remember we don't have all the inside info. We can't know the exact concentrations of the ingredients, the quality of the raw materials, or the details of the formulation processes, which can all play a role in the overall product performance. However, our insights and observations are based solely on the publicly available information. It's always a good idea to test out products for yourself, as individual skin reactions can vary greatly. At the end of the day, your skin has the final say!
The Price Differential
IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Dark Spots Niacinamide Serum is noticeably more affordable than Kiehl's Clearly Corrective Dark Spot Corrector, making it an attractive option for those looking to combat dark spots on a budget. The IT Cosmetics serum sells for $35 for 30mL while the Kiehl’s sells for $65 for the same volume. And apparently potentially much more in other geographies!
Conclusion
We've gotta say, given just how similar these products are – not to mention that little extra niacinamide kick in the IT Cosmetics serum – it's really seeming like a no-brainer. If you're hunting for a budget-friendly swap for the Kiehl's serum, the IT Cosmetics serum might just be what you're looking for. We're super thrilled to have been able to lend a hand to our community member with this find. It's always a bit of a rush when we're able to make these discoveries.
You might also want to read:
- Dare we say, we've found a great Goop dupe
- Gold stabilized vitamin C, what is it?
- Only 2 ingredients different, a much more affordable Barbara Sturm Calming Serum alternative
