Quick Summary
After thorough assessment, the Meishoku Brilliant Colors Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash stands out as a strong contender and potentially a better match to Dermalogica's Microfoliant Daily than the previously considered TonyMoly I’m From Rice Exfoliating Enzyme Cleanser. With both enzymes and salicylic acid in its formula—features we hadn't found in other affordable alternatives—Detclear proves to be an effective and budget-friendly dupe for Dermalogica's popular microfoliant.
Introduction
At Skinskool, we love diving into the nitty-gritty of ingredient lists to bring you objective product comparisons. Today, we're putting the Meishoku Brilliant Colors Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash under the microscope to see if it can be considered a true dupe for the Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily. We've long had the I’m From Rice Exfoliating Enzyme Cleanser on our radar as a fantastic affordable alternative, but recent discoveries have us thinking Detclear might be an even better match. Let's dive into the details.
Ingredient Comparison
Let's break down the ingredients of the Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash and the Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily. Meishoku Detclear combines papain, an enzyme derived from papaya, with salicylic acid, a BHA known for its pore-penetrating exfoliation. This dual-action approach effectively tackles dead skin cells on both the surface and within the pores. Additionally, Detclear features a variety of fruit extracts—like pear, bilberry, and apple—which bring antioxidant benefits and gentle exfoliation to the table. Corn starch in the formula also offers a gentle physical exfoliation, adding another layer to its multi-faceted approach.
On the other hand, Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily uses papain for enzymatic exfoliation, along with microcrystalline cellulose and magnesium oxide for a gentle physical scrub. Colloidal oatmeal is included to soothe and calm the skin, while rice bran extract provides gentle exfoliation and conditioning. Salicylic acid is also present, ensuring deep cleaning and acne-fighting benefits. The addition of tea tree leaf oil brings antimicrobial properties, helping to maintain clear skin.
Previously, we considered the TonyMoly I’m From Rice Exfoliating Enzyme Cleanser the best affordable alternative due to its papain and rice-based exfoliants. However, its lack of salicylic acid limits its ability to penetrate pores and combat acne, making Meishoku Detclear a more comprehensive alternative.
Claims and Functionality
Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash claims to deliver multi-faceted exfoliation through its enzymatic, chemical, and mild physical actions. Papain gently breaks down proteins on the skin's surface, while salicylic acid penetrates pores to address acne and improve overall texture. The fruit extracts not only help exfoliate but also provide antioxidant benefits, protecting the skin from environmental damage. Corn starch offers gentle physical exfoliation, enhancing the product's ability to remove dead skin cells and impurities, leaving the skin smoother.
Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily takes a balanced approach to exfoliation. Microcrystalline cellulose and magnesium oxide offer a gentle physical scrub, while papain ensures enzymatic exfoliation. Colloidal oatmeal helps to soothe and calm the skin, making it suitable for sensitive skin types. Salicylic acid is crucial for pore penetration and deep cleaning, which helps clear acne and refine skin texture. The antimicrobial properties of tea tree leaf oil further support skin clarity and health.
For those sensitive to fragrances, it's worth noting that Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash contains added fragrance. In this case, the I’m From Rice Exfoliating Enzyme Cleanser is an excellent fragrance-free alternative, offering gentle enzymatic exfoliation with rice-based ingredients while being suitable for those with fragrance sensitivities.
Pricing Difference
One of the significant factors to consider when comparing the 2 products, is the price difference. The Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily is a premium product ($66 for 74 g), often retailing at a higher price point, reflecting its high-quality ingredients and brand reputation. On the other hand, the Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash offers a more budget-friendly alternative ($12.30 for 75 g) without compromising on the key exfoliating and skin-enhancing benefits. This makes Detclear an attractive option for those looking to achieve similar skincare results without the premium price tag associated with Dermalogica's offering.
Conclusion
When considering ingredient lists and functionality, the Meishoku Brilliant Colors Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash stands out as an excellent dupe for the Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily. It provides similar exfoliating benefits through enzymatic, chemical, and mild physical actions, along with additional antioxidant properties from various fruit extracts. For beauty enthusiasts seeking an effective yet budget-friendly alternative to Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily, the Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash is highly recommended. However, for those who prefer or need a fragrance-free product, the TonyMoly I’m From Rice Exfoliating Enzyme Cleanser remains a top choice.
Choosing Meishoku Detclear Fruits Enzyme Powder Wash allows users to enjoy the benefits of an effective and affordable exfoliant that closely mirrors the performance of Dermalogica Microfoliant Daily. This makes it an attractive option for achieving smooth, clear skin without the higher price tag associated with Dermalogica's offering.
