Discover alternatives in sync with your needs, budget and values. We compare, you decide.

Include same brand

Best Il Makiage Icon Mascara dupes and ingredient-based alternatives

Quick Summary of Target Product

Skip to results

Mascaras

They say: For eyes to bat your way out of a parking ticket. Icon weightlessly lifts, separates, curls and thickens every lash for serious drama. Our quick-drying formula settles without hardening and offers unprecedented buildability that never clumps. Our uniquely designed, football-shaped silicon brush has exceptional control and can grip & coat even the tiniest lashes from root to tip for a... For eyes to bat your way out of a parking ticket. Icon weightlessly lifts, separates, curls and thickens every lash for serious drama. Our quick-drying formula settles without hardening and offers unprecedented buildability that never clumps. Our uniquely designed, football-shaped silicon brush has exceptional control and can grip & coat even the tiniest lashes from root to tip for a high-impact fanned-out effect.

Trending Deals

iHERB - 15% off over $60 / 20% off over $100 using Code: JUN26SW

AP Beauty - Double Cleanse + Hydrate Duo 15% Off Bundle A.O. Essence + A.O. Reboot & Renew Cream

MARIO BADESCU - Get 15% off All Mario Badescu Products using code SKINSKOOL15

DRMTLGY - Get 20% Off using code SKINSKOOL

SKINCARE GENERICS - Get 10% Off Sitewide using code SKINSKOOL

We earn commission from sales tracked via affiliate links. We greatly appreciate users who shop through our links! Terms of Use

Deep Dive

Dr. Dennis Gross Peel Pads Are One of the Most-Requested Dupes We Get. Here's What Actually Compares.

We compared the formula in one of the most-requested dupes in our inbox — and the $34 difference isn't even the most interesting part.

Skincare Compare™ Roundup of Top Matches by INCI List Similarity

We've tracked 62,135 product ingredient INCI lists and these are the products with the most number of similar ingredients. Results are based on the degree to which a product contains the ingredients of the target product.

Our comparison review is based solely on publicly available ingredient lists and we do not make any statements regarding comparison of formulation, processes or product efficacy.